Haters gonna hate... (by jzink-71827) |
This movie was stunning and beautiful. Very well made, and for the haters, I think it was just too smart for them. Its not some spoonfed action nonsense. You have to actually pay attention and enjoy the suspense. |
Surprise of the Year. (by curtd-49392) |
I shouldn't be surprised by the negative reviews, but I am. Hold the dark was well cast, well acted, well written, well shot, brilliant, dreamlike, almost surreal, as we follow a confused lead though, an unpredictably evolving different plots in every act - and I was riveted the entire time. It is unfortunate that those of us who love this form have so few opportunities to enjoy it, but this one will be rewatched every year or so, and enjoyed every time. |
One of the best movies I've ever seen (by celtic451) |
Ignore the haters on this one. I don't get all of the negative reviews. This movie was simply amazing. Great acting, great plot makes you think , great scenery, and great score. It brilliantly show through the action and attitudes of the local people how the outside world just doesn't get it and they refuse to give up their culture, whether you are native or not, the culture and traditions and spirituality comes from the land and the magic of the land not from genetic makeup. Skarsgaard is dead on in this role. If you like something deeper than a Vin D. movie then this is for you. |
Beautifully Captivating (by ClaviculaNox) |
There are so much negative reviews but it's really beautiful. Most of the reviews written is because they didn't understand the plot of the movie or what it represents. It's a deeply dark movie on so many levels. It's a story inside a story, the mother killed her son because she was living in the dark. As her husband is her brother. Incist. And there are many implications and hints across the movie that shows that "indirectly." The scene when he was looking for his wife in the hotel, the woman said "you both have the same eyes and same hair" The Indian <more> |
What's inside that screen... It gets in you. (by ryansalamence) |
I'm an enormous fan of Jeremy Saulnier. He's solidified himself as one of my favorite directors due to how absolutely solid his last two films were, they're among my favorite films of all time. If you enjoy Jeremy's directing, you'll definitely enjoy this film as well. Jeremy's strengths are at their strongest here. Unrelenting, Unexpected and unforgiving violence. Breathtaking cinematography. Nerve wracking suspense, and his ability to completely subvert expectations are all extremely present and shining. Him and Macon Blair's "less is more" writing <more> |
Different TV experience (by justice_for_allro) |
I've seen Saulnier's previous work Green Room and Blue Ruin and liked both movies although there were no clear messages sent throughout them. Hold the dark is another kind of thriller, set in Alaska and it projects a supernatural feel to it even from the beginning. What kept me glued to the screen was the setting, the score and the potential story that wasn't actually developed in a linear way. Its pace was very polarized as well, fast paced at times, especially during the "action" scenes and slow in the development of the main story/mystery involving the child's <more> |
Bleak doesn't equate to boring (by michelleecooney) |
This was a fantastic film. The acting was solid, stoic, and appropriate for the subject matter. The cinematography was absolutely stunning; leave it to Saulnier to remind us just how red blood really is against the snow.The story itself was bleak. Bleak doesn't mean boring. On the contrary, this film is a commentary on the darkness in human nature. Yes the ending is ambiguous, yes it is a slow burn, and yes the subject matter is bleak. I believe these three things only constitute a bad film in the eyes of someone whose idea of perfect cinema is superhero movies. I cannot state this loudly <more> |
Read the book after. Then watch again. Ending explained. (by jribeiro739) |
After watching Hold The Dark I felt compelled to read the novel by William Giraldi. After my first time watching the movie I was really left with many questions that needed answering. The movie was well shot and every scene seemed to keep me wondering how the movie would come to an end. After reading the novel I then understood the movie in its entirety. Here is the movie explained.The Slones are twins! Throughout the movie there is always mention of how similar they look or how they have shared a long past. Medora in the beginning of the movie when answering Core about how long she knew him <more> |
Explanation Post (by aguti-09325) |
Smart, well edited, and it held my attention. I read some previous reviews, mostly negative, some positive. Nevertheless, I am here to explain the points and subplots of this movie.1 Husband and wife are indeed brother and sister. Same hair, Norwegian, same eyes, a small part actor pointed that out 3/4 of the movie in. Picture of two young blond children 2/3 of the movie in. Wife tells main character traveler, she doesn't remember a time not knowing her husband, 10 mins into the movie.2 Reason mother killed her own child. Main character traveler says " sometimes wolves kill the <more> |